We are at a significant crossroads.
For those of you who need a refresher on the importance of our Comprehensive plan, please bear with me.
The Comprehensive Plan is the document that guides our public, it directs capital improvements, evaluates development projects, and most importantly– ensures that Islamorada is the place its RESIDENTS want it to be.
This reminder is necessary.
After spending two years in developing the plan, the “final draft” was presented to the public September 30. Jason King of Able City East, the contractor for the Comp plan, commented that what he heard loud and clear from the Village residents over and over for the last two years, can be summed up by “residents want to limit growth or our paradise will be lost.”
That is what the residents emphatically want.
Are you listening, Village Council and staff?
The Comp Plan is a critical document with vital issues focused on Islamorada’s future and yet where is the public involvement, the enthusiasm, the concerns?
Those attending the presentation of the “final draft” consisted of 3 members of council, 4 members of Village staff, and just 10 members of the public. Little public comment.
The new comp plan cannot be implemented until the corresponding Land Development Regulations (LDR) are also modified and that review has not even been started.
Why not? Who is in charge?
Next step was the Nov 9 LPA meeting last week. The LPA is tasked with reviewing the draft Comprehensive Plan and making their recommendations to council.
Two members of council attended but no residents attended?
Florida SB180: The Village attorney warned the LPA that the Florida Legislature passed SB180 in 2025. It bars Florida local governments from adopting “more restrictive or burdensome” land use changes from August 1, 2024, through October 1, 2027.
What is the status of the Village request for a modification of that rule?
The LPA meeting included little more than one hour of discussion. Two more LPA meetings were scheduled for Dec 7 and Dec 14 to discuss the first 3 of 11 chapters of the plan: Future Land Use, Transportation and Housing.
Last week most of the LPA’s hour-long discussion was about how to provide a way to return to land use designations with uses allowed by the County prior to the incorporation of Islamorada in 1998.
What is the reasoning behind that? Isn’t change, perhaps downsizing, one of the reasons we incorporated?
They seemed to echo the interest of at least one local land use attorney who, at a recent council meeting, stated that those map issues have been his “bread and butter” for years.
He assists clients in getting through the process of changing the Future Land Use Maps and Zoning Maps that were modified by the Village after incorporation.
We went back and looked.
Since the Village maps were approved over 20 years ago, there have been 134 ordinances approved by Village Councils that have changed the zoning or future land use maps for individual properties. (though certainly not all via this one land use attorney)
Nearly all of the changes requested are considered “UPZONING.” THAT MEANS INCREASING THE DENSITY OR INTENSITY OF USE!
Past Village Council decisions have been consistently the opposite of the “limit growth or our paradise will be lost” direction Able City says has been prevalent in their work with Islamorada stakeholders and staff.
Paying attention?
Very few properties in Islamorada are still owned by the same property owner who bought with uses allowed by the County prior to incorporation.
Most current property owners bought their properties since the Village regulations were implemented over 20 years ago. They should have been well aware of the restrictive nature of Village regulations impacting their purchase.
The Village Councils apparently didn’t get the memo.
This map question is just one issue in a complex 253-page document that will guide the Village for years to come.
We hope that the public will read the Comp Plan draft, at least the sections that are of personal interest to each of you.
Then, step two, show up to fight for the future of Islamorada.
The residents asked for “limited growth or our paradise will be lost.”
Anybody in the new Village Council or LPA listening?
Beware of those painting a “all is well” picture for the Village future.
It is obvious they have another agenda, can’t hear and/or ignore their residents voice.
We are at a crucial juncture and this requires all hands on deck.
Send your councilperson the message you gave regarding the Comp plan revision - “limited growth or we will lose our paradise”.
It’s your move!
Tom